Dunno...the Ann Arbor Trail/Penniman houses seem to be similar architecture, time period (and some rival the size) of the places in Shaker
we eyeballed. Plymouth may have a bit more going on (currently live music from a "Green" festival downtown) can be heard from our bedroom window, some new bars and restaurants, etc. etc. etc.
Anyhoo. To the poster above, we agreed with your assessment of Asiatown; seemed very safe, but not very walkable. We did hit Koko bakery last weekend for bubble tea, and just got back from another recon expedition and had dim sum at the restaurant down the street on Payne.
We loved Tremont on a Friday night...but the place we looked at had VERY limited parking (we both work and need two cars)...and Fairfield between Paralax (loved the onion ring side with the sushi) and Lolita seemed to get clogged up pretty quickly.
Ohio City, some lovely little side-streets with beautiful brick Victorian homes, but to pull another Detroit comparison, reminded me a bit of Corktown.
Ultimately, I think we are go with a 1 BR 1100 sqft loft we found in the Warehouse district. Rent will be a bit more, but per mapquest only 4 miles to the main CCF campus, and there is a satellite on the west side I will be trudging too so this works perfectly.
Thanks for the help!