I had the same problem where I was trying to decide between Ohio City and Tremont. I ultimately decided on renting in Ohio City (as of today!). I had a tour of the Merrell building a few weeks ago. The property manager (owner, too, I believe) is a really nice guy! I'm moving from Columbus so I didn't know much about the area and he took us on an impromptu tour of Ohio City. I don't know how much help that is, but I would feel pretty comfortable in those two buildings. (The Merrell building has an awesome location--right across from West Side Market!)