The Diary of a Cleveland, Ohio Industrial Building

 

If buildings could have diaries, the complex of industrial structures along Ashland Road in Cleveland, Ohio would be overflowing with details on its long and illustrious history. Not much has been written about the complex, owing to a lack of information easily available, and misinterpretations based on various first-hand accounts and urban explorers. But what was uncovered was fascinating and complicated, more so than originally envisioned, and despite a wealth of materials uncovered, there are still gaps that have not yet been resolved.

 

Founded in 1796 near the mouth of the Cuyahoga River, Cleveland became a manufacturing hub due to its location along Lake Erie and along several canals and railroads that branched out like limbs on a tree. To connect its growing neighborhoods with its bustling downtown, streetcars powered by horses and mules were used, but there was a push to electrify these lines by 1890. In the spring of 1888, the East Cleveland Railroad Company, one of many streetcar  companies, began constructing a power plant at Cedar Avenue and Ashland Road to operate their lines by electricity.

 

Below is a postcard from the Walter C. Leedy Collection at the Michael Schwartz Library Special Collections, Cleveland State University.

 

 

The new Cedar Avenue Power House was opened on December 18, 1888 and featured three high speed engines belted to two No. 16 Edison street railway bipolar generators, the largest of Edison's generators, which operated at 1,000 RPMs. Three horizontal tubular boilers, equipped with Murphy stokers, supplied steam to the engines. One Berryman heater, with two pumps, supplied the boilers, and a 175-foot smokestack was constructed. Also inside was a hand crane of eight-tons capacity built by Phoenix Iron Works of Cleveland. Upon the starting of the power plant, four electrical cars were in operation and the East Cleveland Street Railway extended its electric service to Public Square on its Euclid line in July 1889.

 

Below are photographs taken in 2012 of the Cedar Avenue Power House. The original windows, with their arches, were modified, and the smokestacks long dismantled.

 

 

 

 

 

The plant was expanded in late 1889 with three high speed Armington & Sims engines of 250 HP and 200 RPM each. The new engines were twice the capacity of the first three engines, and were belted to two No. 32 Edison generators, twice the size of the originals. Four additional boilers were added, as well as a 135-foot high smokestack. Below is a photograph of the new engine. From Woodward, H.W. "The Evolution of Electric Railway Power Plant Apparatus, as Illustrated by the Cedar Avenue Station of the Cleveland Electric Railway Co." The Engineer 39.7 (1 Apr. 1902).

 

 

The boiler plant can be seen below. From Woodward, H.W. "The Evolution of Electric Railway Power Plant Apparatus, as Illustrated by the Cedar Avenue Station of the Cleveland Electric Railway Co." The Engineer 39.7 (1 Apr. 1902).

 

 

 

 

The next year saw the addition with two Cooper Corliss engines belted to a large jack shaft and seven boilers. A third Corliss engine was installed two years later, and the three original engines were removed soon after - replaced with an Allis engine the same size as the Corliss, belted to two 150 KW Edison bipolar generators. Below are two photographs of the engines. From Woodward, H.W. "The Evolution of Electric Railway Power Plant Apparatus, as Illustrated by the Cedar Avenue Station of the Cleveland Electric Railway Co." The Engineer 39.7 (1 Apr. 1902).

 

 

 

Yet another addition was finished in 1892 with four Cooper Corliss single cylinder engines rated at 750 HP and belted to a 500 KW General Electric four-pole generator, operating at 350 RPMs. Eventually, there were two batteries of seven and one battery of ten boilers, each being 18 feet by 72 inches and featuring 72 four-inch tubes rated at 130-horsepower. They were equipped with Murphy stokers and located adjacent to the C&P railroad tracks so that coal could be unloaded into the boiler room, directly in front of the furnace doors.

 

In 1893, the East Cleveland Railway Company merged with Joseph Stanley's Broadway & Newburgh Street Railroad Company to form the Cleveland Electric Railway Company. It soon added Tom and Al Johnson's Brooklyn Street Railroad Company and the South Side Street Railroad Company. Soon after, the Cleveland Electric was better known as the Big Consolidated.

 

A new boiler house was constructed in that year, consisting of ten 400 HP Babcock & Wilcox boilers. In 1897, foundations for a new power house was laid. An engineer for the company described the new plant, which would include compound engines that would supersede the single cylinder units, and multipolar direct connected generators to supplant the belted two- and four-pole machines.  At its peak, the power house featured seventeen generators of 140 to 1,000 amperes capacity each.

 

On January 1, 1899, a new 400-ton, 32-foot high General Electric generator - one of the largest in the world, was installed - measuring a whopping 4,363 amperes. It's size was second only to one ordered by the Metropolitan Electrical Company of New York and a duplicate of an order by the Louisville Street Railway Company. The fly wheel attached was 25 feet in diameter and weighed 160,000 pounds alone. Steam for the new engine was provided by a battery of ten steel boilers built by the Babcock & Wilson Company of New York, and were constructed to withstand a pressure of 200 pounds-per-square-inch. The Cedar Avenue facility was the largest non-condensing direct-current plant in the United States, and was operated non-condensing because the exhaust steam was sold to a salt company adjacent at a price that made it difficult for the central station companies in Cleveland to compete with the Cleveland Railway's power house on a per-kilowatt-hour output.

 

Below is a photograph of the engine room of the Cedar Avenue Power House, now empty and stripped of value.

 

 

An engineer with the Big Consolidated Street Railroad discussed about the power plant's future at that time, stating that electrical power distribution, similar to what was being instituted by the Metropolitan Company of New York, may be implemented for Cleveland. Land would be purchased at an area outside of the city, where land is cheap and water plentiful, and the current transmitted to substations within Cleveland where it would be distributed to various streetcar lines. The main wires would be laid in conduits and carry an alternating current of at least 6,000 volts. At the substations, the current would be passed through rotary convertors and transformed into a direct current of 500 volts.

 

In mid-1901, Big Consolidated added a storage battery facility, which consisted of 216 cells with a normal rating of 4,000 ampere hours, weighing 2,500-pounds per cell. A differential booster, installed by the Bullock Electric Manufacturing Company of Cincinnati, was connected to the storage battery.

 

Below is a 1913 Sanborn map showing the battery facility on the southwest corner of Cedar Avenue and Ashland Road.

 

 

Below is a photograph from Woodward, H.W. "The Evolution of Electric Railway Power Plant Apparatus, as Illustrated by the Cedar Avenue Station of the Cleveland Electric Railway Co." The Engineer 39.7 (1 Apr. 1902).

 

 

In 1902, a new coal handing apparatus was installed. An entire car of coal could be brought in on a transfer table and then lifted into an elevator. From there, the coal would follow an overhead track and dumped into an overhead coal storage bin. By this point, the power house was burning through 60,000 tons of coal a year, averaging 215-tons per day during the winter months. The plant also consumed 50,000 cubic feet of water per day. Below is a cross-section of this addition, from Woodward, H.W. "The Evolution of Electric Railway Power Plant Apparatus, as Illustrated by the Cedar Avenue Station of the Cleveland Electric Railway Co." The Engineer 39.7 (1 Apr. 1902).

 

 

On November 15, 1912, the Cleveland Railway outsourced some power generation to the Illuminating Company to offset a power plant that was over capacity. In 1916, Cleveland Railway requested permission from city commissioners to rebuild and enlarge the power plant at a cost of $345,000, stating that the equipment was obsolete. The request was made initially in July 1915 but no action was taken. The company noted that $95,000 would be taken from the maintenance fund and $250,000 be classified as capital. Street Railway Commissioner Fielder Sanders investigated the need of the improvements, and whether it would be cheaper to outsource all power generation instead of improving the existing facilities. It was later decided that the cost to upgrade the Cedar Avenue power plant was prohibitively expensive. The production value at the Cedar Avenue facility was $1.2 million, and this, deducting the salvage of machinery and equipment estimated at $115,565, could be paid off at a rate of $20,000 per month. The cost of outsourcing electric production to the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company was less than 6 mills per kw. The cost of energy production in the Cedar Avenue plant was about 1 cent per kw.

 

Below is a 1913 Sanborn Insurance map of the power plant.

 

 

After the Cleveland Railway Company left the Cedar Avenue power house in 1917, three one- and two-story structures were used by the Cleveland Ice Machine Company. Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Company post-1922 used the structure to manufacture and sell circuit breakers, elevator motors and controls, fans, fuses, insulating materials, lamps, lighting fixtures, motors, panelboards, ranges, safety switches, small turbines, solar glow heaters, stokers, switchboards, water heaters, watshour meters and welding equipment. A five-story addition on the southern end of the plant, 2203-2209 Ashland Road, was completed in 1922 of reinforced concrete with a brick exterior. It contained "Westinghouse Electric" over the primary entrance.

 

 

On April 10, 1933, Westinghouse transferred its local sales and service offices to Edgewater Park, where an existing lighting products division was located.

 

Three years later, on January 26, Thompson Products purchased several buildings from the Cleveland Railway Company. Containing 60,000 square feet os space, it housed the company's service division. Thompson Products originated in 1901 as the Cleveland Cap Screw Company, with their initial products being bolts with heads electrically welded to the shafts. They soon expanded to automobile engine valves and soon were the largest valve manufacturer in the United States. Some of their high-performance valves were later used in aircraft engines beginning with World War I. In 1926, the company was renamed Thompson Products after the general manager, Charles Thompson.

 

On January 10, 1941, Tapco, or Thompson Aircraft Products Company, was founded as a subsidiary of Thompson Products, and called the Ashland Road facility its base. Production under Tapco soared due to the escalation of World War II, and made not only valves, but new products such as booster pumps and high-altitude fuel systems.

 

Following victory over Japan and the conclusion of World War II, Thompson Products saw a rapid decline in defense production. During the month following V-J Day, or August 14, 1945, the company noted more than 3,000 cancelled contracts, or more than $50 million in total value. By the end of August, Tapco employed just 650, down from 12,000 at the peak of war. But by the spring of 1946, an estimated 3,600 would be hired back due to increasing demand for automotive values and parts.

 

On September 20, Thompson Products announced an agreement to purchase land for a Tapco plant in Euclid, which would then serve as corporate headquarters and manufacturing hub. Five days later, Thompson announced a reorganization of its Cleveland-area operations into five divisions based on product lines. Four of the five units, Light Metals - its aluminum foundry operations, Piston Ring, Parts and Accessories and Valve and Jet Propulsion, were housed at Tapco, with only the Special Products Division - automotive replacement parts and other forged-metal products located at its main plant.

 

Following World War II, Thompson began focusing heavily in aerospace and defense contracts, especially during the ramp up to the Vietnam War and Cold War.

 

A 1951 Sanborn map noted that the Westinghouse Electric plant was home to Tapco, Pump Division:

 

2203-2209 Ashland Road was the six-story service building.

2176-2203 Ashland Road were manufacturing areas, one- to two-stories in height.

2151-2175 Ashland Road was a finished products warehouse, five-stories in height.

2225-2229 Ashland Road was a three-story machine shop.

Other portions of the Thompson Products plant extended across the railroad tracks towards East 65th Street and north to Cedar Avenue.

 

Below is a 1951 Sanborn Insurance map.

 

 

Thompson Products merged with Ramo-Wooldridge in October 1958. An April 27, 1959 article listed the Ashland Road facilities as part of Thompson-Ramo-Wooldridge's Light Metals division. On January 27, 1961, Thompson-Ramo-Wooldridge announced plans to acquire a 55-acre tract in suburban Independence for a $3 million master warehouse and headquarters for its automotive replacement parts division, which would replace their Ashland Road and Cedar Avenue facilities. The new warehouse would be located on Pleasant Valley Road east of Ohio Route 21, and include 320,000 square-feet of warehouse space and 50,000 square-feet of office space on one level. On November 1, 1962, Thompson-Ramo-Wooldridge, later known as TRW, sold their Ashland Road structures for approximately $500,000 to Albert A. Levin, a Cleveland attorney and realty investor. The continued to occupy the buildings now used by the Light Metals division under terms of a five-year lease. Buildings formerly housing Thompson-Ramo-Wooldridge's replacement facilities in Independence were leased to other tenants.

 

After Thompson vacated, the Ashland Road plant became home to the Virden Manufacturing Company. Originally named the Howler Manufacturing Company, the business was renamed after John C. Virden, the president. In October 1919, his factory relocated to a building along Longfellow Avenue near its intersection with Longfellow Avenue.

 

Below is a 1913 Sanborn Insurance Map showing the Virden Manufacturing Company along Longfellow Road.

 

 

In 1920, a two-story, 40-by-92-foot addition at Ashland Road and Longfellow Avenue, designed by E. McGeorge, was let to contract in May for $60,000. Five years later, a contract was awarded to the Griffin Construction Company of Cleveland for a one-story machine shop and storage building also designed by McGeorge, measuring 40-feet by 80-feet. Another expansion took place in mid-1936, when a contract was awarded to the Albert M. Higley Company, and again in mid-1940 when a new two-story 150-by-70-foot warehouse was built by the Higley Company. Over the ensuing years, the company expanded into the manufacture of fluorescent and incandescent lighting equipment, and then into commercial and residential lighting products.

 

Below is a 1951 Sanborn Insurance Map showing the Virden Manufacturing Company along Longfellow Road with its assorted expansions.  By 1963, portions of Virden had spilled over to the former TRW facilities along Ashland Road.

 

 

By 1968, Virden was the third largest among the nation's 1,400 fixture manufacturers, with production tripling from eight years prior. The company sold more than 1,000 varieties from its biennial catalog, and produced 10,000 to 15,000 fixtures per day, consuming more than a million components per week. Virden constructed 600 to 800 units of one design per run, which were moved to distributors in lots of 10 to 2,000 per week, some designs totaling 150,000 units per year. Its designers sketched 2,500 fixtures per year, selecting 100 patterns to be prototyped.

 

In 1946, Virden was elected a director of Eaton Manufacturing Company and became director of the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland in January 1951 - later rising to chairman of the board. On September 28, 1958, Virden was named president of Eaton Manufacturing Company and diversified the company, believing in "divisional autonomy." He also announced his resignation as chairman of the board of the Virden Company. In 1965, the Virden Company was acquired by Scott & Fetzer Company of suburban Lakewood, with no changes taking place at its operations at Longfellow Avenue. The company became known as the Virden Lighting division.

 

In 1970, Scott & Fetzer laid off several hundred from the Virden Lighting division due to a housing slump, and again in 1975. The company sold off its Virden Lighting and Rembrandt Lamp divisions in December 1977 to a newly formed company, Virden Corporation, which at the time of the sale had 360 employees.

 

On August 6, 1979, Virden failed to make payment to 300 employees. According to the company, Virden had closed three days prior because of a parts shortage, but Robert M. Allen of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 1554 stated that the company owned Cleveland Trust Company $5 million and Scott & Fetzer Company $2 million - and paid them first instead of its employees. Virden's president stated that he hoped Virden would be open by the end of the week, but employees were officially laid off in January 1980. On October 28-31, a complete auction was held at the Virden Lighting Company, including its metal working machinery, punch presses, lathes, machine shop, $700,000 in inventory, $1 million in parts, print shop and real estate.

 

Prior to 1987, the property from Cedar Avenue to Thackeray Avenue along Ashland Road was transferred to Weiser Management Inc. A quit claim deed for $60,000 was filed on July 7, 2008 to Bleacher Beast Inc., who was foreclosed upon on February 28, 2012. On June 21, the parcels were transferred to Sandusky Solutions LLC.

 

What is still unknown is when Thompson-Ramo-Wooldridge officially vacated their Ashland Road facility and what time period the Cleveland Ice Company occupied the complex.

 

Below are photographs taken in 2012 of the former power house. The structure has most recently been salvaged of any value, including portions of the structural trusses which are now held together with cables. The tour starts in the 1888 building. Note the cuts in the structural truss.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

An August 1980 calendar.

 

 

 

 

 

Looking southward towards the 1922 Westinghouse addition.

 

 

A view of the 1922 Westinghouse addition.

 

 

 

The below photograph shows one of the later additions to the power house, exhibited by its wider wood-board roof and contemporary steel girders.

 

 

A view of one of the older additions, with pin-connected trusses and narrow wood-board roof. For an industrial structure, pin-connected trusses are very rare; they were more often used in early-1900-era truss bridges.

 

 

 

Tremendous write-up and photos! Thanks!!

Urban porn!!! Thank you! So depressing how many amazing buildings are going to waste.

Extremely impressive.

If the neighborhood were better, that could be an amazing rehab/housing conversion like Gospel Press in Tremont.

 

Maybe it would do better as a small business/manufacturing incubator. It's right next to the busy Chicago-Pittsburgh-East Coast tracks of NS (and Amtrak) which sends 70+ trains a day by there. So I doubt it would be a good housing development.

Bravo, bravo, bravo!  Thanks for sharing your wonderful research with us.  I have a particular fascination with how urban sites change over time.  I really enjoyed your writeup and custom photography.

 

Thanks - I have another gem from Cleveland's rail heritage to post in a few days.

 

@KJP: I wish that this could be converted, but after seeing the trusses cut - I'm not sure. Actually, I'm not sure how that was allowed to happen in the first place. Also striking against it is that it is zoned for industrial - but I would otherwise LOVE to see this turned into condos. I would appreciate the 70+ trains rolling by! (And boy, did they go by every few minutes at 30-40 MPH seemingly).

Nice (make that excellent) work Sherman.  This building has been on my radar for a while.  I actually went out of my way over Christmas last year to drive down Ashland Rd. to see what the landscape was like.

 

I realize that the neighborhood around it is not very good...it actually almost seems desolate on the Longfellow/Thackeray side of the property.

Also...literally across Ashland Rd. at the corner of Cedar (southwest corner, I believe) is an AWESOME looking building related to this one...it looks like a far cooler version of the power station in Ohio City that the Cle Museum of Art is rehabbing for gallery space.  Once again...the disadvantage here is that the location would probably not support any type of project like that. 

 

So...dumb question to the fellow CLE urbanophiles on this board...how do I contact the owner of this place?  Is it owned by Sandusky Solutions? 

 

ChiCleveKid: That was the Cleveland Railway Co. Cedar Ave. Substation that effectively replaced the power house (shown above) after they outsourced their power generation.

 

As for the owner: no clue. It's one hell of a shady company, and they purchased it to most likely scrap it of any contents, or to at least hold it. The scrapping inside took place pretty recently - at least within a few months to a year, and was professionally done.

Thanks for the quick follow up, Sherman. 

I plan on trying to track down the owner of this place...at some point.

Do you know what the actual street address is?

I found the addresses of the buildings on Ashland in your work...but I wonder if the main power facility holds a Cedar address?

 

http://fiscalofficer.cuyahogacounty.us/AuditorApps/real-property/REPI/General.asp

Parcel No. 118-21-001

Address: SANDUSKY SOLUTIONS LLC, 02175-02187 ASHLAND RD, CLEVELAND, 44103

Tax Address: SANDUSKY SOLUTIONS LLC, 9401 SANDUSKY AVE, CLEVELAND, OH 44105 (aerial: http://goo.gl/maps/XG4y)

C/O: Kimberly Scott

 

That's about as much as I can pull up at the moment.

You know, the county is looking for 200,000 square feet of space for a consolidated storage facility. This might be a good location if the trusses can be repaired.

http://www.cleveland.com/business/index.ssf/2012/07/cuyahoga_county_office_search.html

Thanks for the follow up again!

I'll keep all posted on what - if anything - I find out!

Beautiful work. Thank you, Sherman.

yeah great thread.

 

its too bad these property raiders have raped and looted the grounds, but maybe the bldg can still be saved and put to some light industrial use. its still very much worth saving.

 

Sherman, this was such a great read, thanks so much for putting it together!  The current photos are heartbreaking.

Do you have current links to the pictures? I would love to see the visuals when reading this great article but the links appear broken. Thank you! 

@seicer doesn't post as often as he used to. So in the meantime, @mcvvan this might be worth sifting through: https://www.facebook.com/pg/photographybychrisv/photos/?tab=album&album_id=460373144153277