Jump to content

Featured Replies

this is just a bad design...what are they thinking?

  • Replies 104
  • Views 7.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I would agree that the building has been butchered.

 

 

Cincymls.com still works for me...

what a waste!

Maybe we should contact the developer and tell him what an idiot he is!  No, but seriously, maybe we could actually have an impact by hinting that this is not the design that will maximize profits.  I'm not joking.  If these guys heard a unanimously negative reaction from a bunch of young urbanists (i.e. the demographic that is likely to buy these units) like us, they might be inclined to change it.  This suggestions will get laughed at, no doubt, but I'm just trying to move from theory to action.

I like old original exterior shells with modern interiors..I would never buy a unit there, I'm not even interested to go and look at it by that rendering.

  • 5 weeks later...

Picture from last week, heading south on Ashland just north of Victory Parkway...

 

SchoolhouseLofts.jpg

Some shots from about a half hour ago:

 

SchoolhouseLofts20050226_01.jpg

 

SchoolhouseLofts20050226_02.jpg

 

SchoolhouseLofts20050226_03.jpg

 

Nice shots...thanks for the update.

Actually, it is not that bad we have a pretty good historical society and many structures from the past still remain but it is sad when newer development doesn't queu the past.

  • 1 month later...

Update from this morning - they've torn a bunch of the roof off:

 

SchoolhouseLofts20050403_01.jpg

 

SchoolhouseLofts20050403_02.jpg

 

SchoolhouseLofts20050403_03.jpg

I think the project looks great, and the neighborhood would really benefit too once it is complete.

Wow.  How did I miss that rendering!  I guess it looks ok, but I was really expecting something much, much  more from this project.  It's too bad because this really seemed like a great opportunity. 

 

Thanks for the updated pics, RiverViewer.

I guess it looks ok, but I was really expecting something much, much more from this project. It's too bad because this really seemed like a great opportunity.

 

it's been proven time and time again that developers in this city simply can't do better than that.  a real shame...

  • 2 weeks later...

The units are still hanging tough at $225,000 (with some for less), and I noticed that sale is pending on a couple of them.

 

EDIT: According to DCI, 7 had been pre-sold by early February.  I'm thinking they have to be at least halfway there (to 31) by now.

  • 2 months later...

An update from this evening:

 

45878430.jpg

Good to see.  It seemed like they didn't do anything for a while there.

  • 2 weeks later...

It's nice to see work moving along, though it sucks to see that much of that work has been on the ass-ugly roof extension thing that I don't believe anybody liked...

 

Thanks for the pictures!

  • 1 month later...

It might be time for some more pics.  That recessed top part is completely enclosed now.

Ask and you shall receive, pics from today.

 

48122611.jpg

 

48122612.jpg

 

48122614.jpg

Sorry we asked!

^haha.  the stone addition just does not blend well with the existing yellow paper

I drove by the other day and it really doesnt look that bad in person. At least it's being used...

 

  • 1 month later...

Apparently, construction on some garages is going to start soon.  I didn't know anything about these and I have no idea what they're going to be.  All of the renderings I've ever seen (including the one on the website) has a gated surface lot.

 

BTW...here's the project website:

http://www.schoolhouselofts.net/pages/default.asp

 

The top reminds me of a mortarboard.  Too bad they couldn't put the historic roof back on, that top unit could have been pretty cool with vaulted ceilings underneath it!

you'd think they would reference the same elevation when comparing the "old" with the "new" on their website. 

  • 1 month later...

That top part that everyone loves so much is pretty much done, and most of the windows are in:

 

051107006woodburns4qm.jpg

Looks like an odd combination of building materials.....however I do like that they used the old structure and found a way to actually USE the building.

The roof was heavily damaged by a fire, I have the exact date in a book at home I wil try to dig up (actually it is written under the pic I posted showing the old roof, I just cropped it out)

  • 3 months later...

A recent photograph, taken about a week and a half ago:

060215106woodburns4rg.jpg

The top is disappointing, but thanks for the update.

Wow...that looks completely atrocious.  That is so utterly ugly...

the top does ruin it a bit.  the windows there are way too small and look stupid.  im disappointed.

They could have salvaged the top from being a complete disaster by cladding it with brick and installing large, symmetrical windows.  But it's a complete disaster.

Looking at it, I don't mind the concept of having a large deck around the entire top floor - but you're right, it would have to be brick.  As it is, "it's a complete disaster" is exactly the right description.

  • 3 months later...

Here are some pics from today (sorry about the power lines)....

 

 

61818742.jpg

 

61818750.jpg

 

61818845.jpg

 

 

Could have been so beautiful...I understand not recreating the spikey roof thing it used to have, and I dig the fenced-in terrace thing, but why on earth did they choose that gray vinyl-siding looking crap?  What a shame...

 

Wow, disappointing.  But I'm sure cost was involved and if it was brick with big wood windows and a real cast irom fence, etc. the units would be much more expensive.  However, the detailing could have been better.

Isn't it possible to give it some sort of facade?  Fake red stone would be so much better...

i mean, i just think window size and placement make such a HUGE difference.  They could have used this material and put in nice, big windows instead of those small, oddly placed ones, and it would have looked 10x better.

agreed, absolute disgrace.  this architect would be of better service by returning to designing the mobile homes he obviously did in his previous job.

the developer probably blew his nose on a photo of the original building and that design was the result...then told the architect to "design" it this way or he would be fired.  i havent been in the profession long...but if there is one thing ive learned its that the architect is not always the designer and that not very often are their opinions valued.

Dang... what a POS!  :-o This is a HUGE dissapointment.. If I was looking for a condo I would pass that place up just because of the top of the buildings appearance.

That is criminal.

  • 11 months later...

Condos kick off rehab plan

BY JOHN ECKBERG | [email protected]

 

PHOTO:http://news.enquirer.com/apps/pbcs.dll/misc?url=/misc/photos_single.pbs&IDato=20070607&IKategori=BIZ01&ID=706070310

 

PHOTO:http://cmsimg.enquirer.com/apps/pbcsi.dll/bilde?Site=AB&Date=20070607&Category=BIZ01&ArtNo=706070310&Ref=V2&Profile=1076&MaxW=315&border=1

 

EAST WALNUT HILLS - Schoolhouse Lofts Condominiums, a $6.5 million residential renovation of the original Walnut Hills High School on Victory Parkway, will be dedicated today at 10 a.m. by Cincinnati Mayor Mark Mallory and other community leaders.

 

The conversion of classrooms at the Romanesque brick school built in 1895 into living rooms represents the first cog in a sweeping neighborhood redevelopment plan created by Cincinnati-based Excalibur Development Corp.

 

 

http://news.enquirer.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070607/BIZ01/706070310/1076/BIZ

I cry for this building everytime I drive past....Thanks for ruining this once grand building!  It actually looked better vacant with weeds growing around the perimeter.

I wonder if this is the best space in the building.  If so, the builder needs to take a tour of OTR and see how rehab is supposed to be done.

Aesthetically this deserves quite a bit of hating, but I'll still give them credit for pulling it off. Getting Victory Parkway going could really do wonders for Uptown overall.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.