Jump to content

Featured Replies

New Marlins ballpark is terrible for area fans

By Ray McNulty

Sunday, February 24, 2008

 

Four years from now, they'll be called the Miami Marlins.  And that's fitting.  Because when the Marlins move into their new $515 million, 37,000-seat, retractable-roof ballpark in 2011 -- the Miami-Dade County Commission unanimously approved the plan last week -- they will no longer be Florida's team.

 

Not any part of Florida north of Boca, anyway.  Not if they're playing on the site of the soon-to-be leveled Orange Bowl.  That's too far away and too tough to get to for most folks living in Palm Beach County and along the Treasure Coast.  Especially us working stiffs.  Especially on weeknights.

 

More at http://www.miamiherald.com

Well the orange bowl area is rough, like the miami arena as there nothing around. At least the arena crowd has bayside to go to before/after a game.

 

However, the surrounding community....not cute, by MTS standards.

The AA Arena, the Miami Arena aka "Pink Elephant" sits empty several blocks away in overtown.

The AA Arena, the Miami Arena aka "Pink Elephant" sits empty several blocks away in overtown.

 

Its the CBS of Basketball.  LOL.  Isn't that "overtown" or do you have to cross under the 395 bridge before you're physically in "overtown"?  I just know, once you pass by that mall...it aint cute!

Overtown starts 2 blocks west of the AA Arena, the Miami Arena is on the 3rd block.

yeah...thats the area.  those clubs over there...whoa.....do not walk alone after leaving one!

How about Green Bay?

If my memory serves, Green Bay is the smallest market in all of professional sports (at least the Big 4). The city is just a little bigger than Erie, PA. :-o

Well this is Florida...so I wouldn't expect things to improve all that much.  Miami has trouble filling Dolphins games (even when they were most recently good).....

 

I have to give you credit, you never let the facts get in your way!!!   :wink:

 

Well thanks for unnecessarily being a dick...again.  My post was not refering to attendance percentages over the last 7 years, or trendline progressions, or whatever else.  It was due to simple observations from a fans point of view.  I have seen years of empty seats there...and I also remember hearing that they have historically struggled to sell-out even playoff games.

And where did you make these observations?  In front of your TV?  I just pointed out that the data doesnt show it!  Why make silly statements like Miami doesn't deserve an NFL team when your own city has a far worse record of supporting a poor team.  I put the little winky thing on there so you would see it as a joke!

Those are really cool looking.

Thats a sweet looking ballpark

I put the little winky thing on there so you would see it as a joke!

 

So apparently you can say whatever you want and get away with it as long as you insert a smiley?  You stay classy...

Just stating the facts.

ah yeah the miami arena.

 

i saw the janet jackson rhythm nation tour show there. hehe. an interesting trivia tidbit from it was that jj had a serious "wardrobe malfunction" during the show -- that was displayed prominently on the big screens behind the stage. at the time i was like  :-o  but i heard from superfans that she did that schtick all the time during that tour. so the "superbowl incident" was really old news for her show.

 

nbc_the_more_you_know.jpg

 

ps -- for comparison here are the boring new mets/yankees stadiums:

 

http://newyork.mets.mlb.com/nym/ballpark/citifield_images.jsp

 

http://newyork.yankees.mlb.com/nyy/ballpark/new_stadium.jsp

 

Janet Jackson?  :laugh:

 

Citi Field = C+

New Yankee Stadium = D

yeah i know, i know janet jackson.  :laugh: a date, free tix, yadda. also, don't forget a nekkid janet was still pretty hot back then.  :wink:

 

q: putting the newer aa arena on prime waterfront property seems like a wrong move -- what do you think?

I'm indifferent, if it wasn't built there, the new condo towers across the street would probably be there instead. It is however, a more desirable location than the Miami Arena IMO.

Janet Jackson?  :laugh:

 

Citi Field = C+

New Yankee Stadium = D

 

haha yeah. exactly.

 

here's my rating for both of them:

dud.jpg

Janet Jackson?  :laugh:

 

Citi Field = C+

New Yankee Stadium = D

 

haha yeah. exactly.

 

here's my rating for both of them:

dud.jpg

 

 

Not to digress too much from the topic, but the reason for the design of Citi Field was to reflect the past history of Ebbets Field where the Brooklyn Dodgers played before being relocated to L.A..  This is a major improvement to the nasty Shea Stadium, which was never officially completed by the way.  The original design for Shea Stadium was to have a complete circular shell, much like the old cookie cutters from the 60' and 70's: Riverfront, Three Rivers, Busch Stadium, etc.

yep --now it's a cookie cutter throwback stadium.

 

 

^correct...which makes the Tampa Bay stadium very worth while

  • 4 months later...

Update on the Marlins new stadium. Perhaps Mr. Bramam should stick to selling BMW's.

 

 

Trial delayed for talks in Marlins stadium lawsuit

By CURT ANDERSON

South Florida Sun-Sentinel.com

3:47 PM EDT, July 10, 2008

 

A judge ordered surprise settlement talks Thursday in a lawsuit challenging a $3 billion public works financing plan that includes money for a new Florida Marlins ballpark.

 

Full article at http://www.sun-sentinel.com/sports/baseball/marlins/sfl-0710marlinssuit,0,3799229.story

 

  • 2 weeks later...

I think Citi Field is the best new ballpark UC/planned. None of these FL parks have anything on it. I wish some of these owners would get away from these theme-park/ballpark fantasy worlds. It's freakin baseball, we don't need a damn waterslide and huge sandbox in outfield. Your son should be sitting beside you watching the game, not building sand castles.

 

Busch is the best looking new ballpark, imo.

  • 6 months later...

It appears to be totally out of context with its neighborhood. It is also very ugly.

It appears to be totally out of context with its neighborhood. It is also very ugly.

 

Super ugly.  Sheeesh!

 

In what neighborhood is this monstrosity going to be built?  I love how they are cashing in on tourist related taxes.  People are not coming to Miami/Dade County.  If they start piling on taxes, even few will come.

^ Agreed. I'm not sure what the folks over @ herald.com are seeing:

 

Do you like the new stadium design?

 

Yes. 1901 84%

No. 361  16%

 

Total Votes:  2262

^ Agreed. I'm not sure what the folks over @herlad.com are seeing:

 

Do you like the new stadium design?

 

Yes. 1901 84%

No. 361  16%

 

Total Votes:  2262

 

Well South Florida is "God's Waiting Room - East".  Its possible that many voters don't have the eye sight and common sense they once had!

In what neighborhood is this monstrosity going to be built?

 

Little Havana.

haha i like it a lot. it's miami-ish enough and at least it's innovative. i take from the rendering it's surrounded by new stadium-related development? good idea. is that officially part of the plan too?

 

what i don't really 100% like is the site location. too bad. but at least it's reusing the old orange bowl site.

 

don't hate too hard on it -- if a retractable roof like that was to be built over cbs people on uo would be going nuts!  :laugh:

 

 

 

In what neighborhood is this monstrosity going to be built?

 

Little Havana.

 

Oh don't worry, the neighborhood won't even see the new stadium. They've barricaded it off by surrounding it with parking garages.

 

Generally-speaking, I like the new ball parks. But this one really looks like crap. I understand why they need a retractable dome in south Florida. The dome-less stadium that they currently use is a big reason why they have such low attendance. But why do they have to make is so ugly?? Why not try to make this part of the neighborhood instead of putting garages on all sides?? Consolidate the garages, create some sort of plaza that feeds into a stretch of retail. It is not like it hasn't been done well already in many other cities...

 

Oh, thank god we didn't build that dome stadium back in the mid 80s...

 

 

is this the spot where the old orange bowl used to be located?

oh wait those building are all garages? oh never mind then. wait is it mixed use/ground floor retail/cafe, etc. yada yada? that might turn out ok.

 

also, dont forget -- if that roof was built over cbs in the 80's we wouldn't have any convention center mess today. problem solved. not to mention the IX likely would have come down for airport expansion by now too.

is this the spot where the old orange bowl used to be located?

Yes

 

 

oh wait those building are all garages? oh never mind then. wait is it mixed use/ground floor retail/cafe, etc. yada yada? that might turn out ok.

alienate the neighbors who can't afford to attend games.  great!  It's baseball, Cubans love baseball.

This is the day and age where the best ballparks are engaging the surrounding community (Denver, Baltimore, Pittsburgh, Chicago), or creating a new one (St. Louis, Cincinnati, San Diego).  This might be an ok design for a football facility, but baseball?  No way.  They messed this one up.

What would renowned Miami urban designer Andres Duany do?

 

This is the day and age where the best ballparks are engaging the surrounding community (Denver, Baltimore, Pittsburgh, Chicago), or creating a new one (St. Louis, Cincinnati, San Diego).  This might be an ok design for a football facility, but baseball?  No way.  They messed this one up.

 

I don't think I could handle living nearby. It seems like a nightmare. I'd want my apt soundproofed lol

Whaaaaaaa???

  • 1 month later...

dumb move on the name change. now it'll get all mixed up with the miami of ohio's team.

  • 2 years later...

That is tackier than the tackiest tract home in N. Olmsted!  I love how the office of cultural affairs is involved in this project.  Can you say, "laughing stock of MLB"?  Its very Las Vegas gaudy in a S. Florida third world kind of way!

6a00d83451b26169e201539224b996970b-pi

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.